M&S vs Aldi Valentine's Meal Deals: A Taste Test Showdown
Valentine's Day meal deals have arrived in supermarkets, offering couples a convenient and festive dining option. While Marks & Spencer is often associated with premium quality, Aldi provides a budget-friendly alternative. This taste test compares the Dine-In for Two deals from both retailers to determine which offers the best value and flavor.
M&S Dine-In for Two Deal Overview
Available from February 11 to 14, the M&S deal includes Coquilles St Jacques (scallops), Two Duck Breasts with Hot Maple Glaze, Creamy Potato Dauphinoise, Pistachio Chocolate Spheres, and a Malbec red wine. The total cost is £35, but with the deal priced at £25 for two, it represents a £10 saving. However, the taste experience fell short of expectations.
Aldi Dine-In for Two Deal Overview
Available from February 10 to 14, the Aldi deal features Tempura Prawns, Two Duck Breasts with Plum and Hoisin Sauce, Parmesan and Truffle Fries, Dark Chocolate and Black Cherry Hearts, and a Toro Loco red wine. The total comes to £20.15, nearly £5 cheaper than M&S, making it an attractive option for those seeking affordability without compromising on quality.
Starter Comparison: Scallops vs Tempura Prawns
The M&S scallops, served in shells with a creamy sauce and mashed potato, were disappointing. The sauce was watery, and the scallops lacked flavor, earning only 1 out of 5 stars. In contrast, Aldi's Tempura Prawns were a standout success. They cooked to a crisp, were meaty, and came with a tangy sweet chilli dip, making them a delightful starter that could easily serve as a main meal.
Main Course Comparison: Duck Breasts
Both supermarkets offered duck breasts, but the preparation and results varied significantly. The M&S duck had confusing instructions, with marinade details missing for oven cooking. The skin failed to crisp, and the meat was chewy, with a bland hot maple sauce. Aldi's duck, however, was straightforward to cook, well-seasoned, and tender. The plum and hoisin sauce added a powerful, flavorful punch that enhanced the dish.
Side Order Comparison: Potatoes vs Fries
M&S's Dauphinoise potatoes were creamy and decadent, topped with Emmental and Cheddar, though they required longer cooking and were very garlicky and rich. Aldi's Parmesan and Truffle Fries crisped up nicely and, once coated with the provided sachets, offered a tangy and well-balanced flavor, proving to be a satisfying alternative.
Dessert Comparison: Chocolate Treats
Aldi's Dark Chocolate and Black Cherry Hearts presented a challenge in removal from the mould, resulting in broken hearts, but the taste was exceptional. The milk chocolate ganache and cherry compote created a posh black forest gateau experience. M&S's Pistachio Chocolate Spheres were bland, with a light mousse and kataifi pastry filling that lacked depth, though the pistachios and chocolate casing were decent.
Overall Verdict and Value
The Aldi meal deal surpassed M&S in every category, including the wine, offering better taste and value. With a total cost of £20.15, it allows for a Valentine's meal at just over £10 per person. While M&S's dauphinoise potatoes were enjoyable, Aldi's overall performance makes it the clear winner for those seeking an affordable yet delicious dining experience this Valentine's Day.
