Aston Villa have taken the significant step of removing World Cup-winning goalkeeper Emi Martinez from his vice-captaincy role, signalling a potential shift in the club's long-term plans. The decision follows a summer of transfer turbulence involving the Argentine international.
Leadership Shakeup at Villa Park
Manager Unai Emery confirmed the leadership change after Thursday's Europa League clash against Maccabi Tel Aviv, where defender Ezri Konsa unexpectedly wore the captain's armband in the absence of regular skipper John McGinn. This marked a departure from established protocol, as Martinez had consistently served as McGinn's deputy since the 2022/23 season.
Emery explained the restructuring, stating: "The first captain is John McGinn. We decided how we are, as well as managing the next captain. Usually, we have another captain, Emi Martinez, as second captain. But now, after speaking with him, I prefer to get him back. Konsa is the next one. Tyrone Mings, with Ollie Watkins too."
The manager's comments reveal that Konsa, Mings, and Watkins now form the revised leadership hierarchy, effectively sidelining Martinez from captaincy duties despite his experience and status within the squad.
Martinez's Uncertain Future
The 32-year-old goalkeeper's position at Villa Park has appeared increasingly uncertain since emotional scenes following last season's final home match against Tottenham Hotspur. Martinez was seen in tears, appearing to bid farewell to supporters, sparking speculation about his future.
This summer, the situation escalated when Martinez expressed his desire to join Manchester United, leading to his temporary exclusion from the starting lineup against Crystal Palace. Although the transfer ultimately collapsed, the episode has cast doubt on his long-term commitment to the club.
While Martinez remains Villa's first-choice goalkeeper ahead of Marco Bizot, his form has noticeably dipped this season. The combination of failed transfer ambitions and diminished leadership responsibilities suggests the club may be preparing for his departure in one of the next two transfer windows.
James Trafford Emerges as Prime Target
Aston Villa are reportedly considering a move for Manchester City's James Trafford as they plan for a future without Martinez. The 23-year-old English goalkeeper represents an intriguing potential solution despite having only joined City for £31 million in the summer.
Trafford's credentials are impressive: he was instrumental in England's Under-21 European Championship triumph, maintaining a perfect clean sheet record throughout the tournament. His subsequent season with Burnley in the Championship saw him achieve 29 clean sheets in 46 appearances, conceding only 16 goals and setting a new record with 12 consecutive clean sheets.
Former manager Scott Parker described Trafford's performances as 'world class', highlighting his potential to develop into an elite goalkeeper. However, his situation at Manchester City has become complicated following the surprise signing of Champions League winner Gianluigi Donnarumma, which has relegated Trafford to second choice.
This development presents an opportunity for Villa, as Trafford requires regular first-team football to continue his development and bolster his chances of featuring in future England squads. His age, potential, and current circumstances make him an attractive candidate to eventually succeed Martinez as Villa's long-term number one.
The coming January transfer window could prove pivotal as Unai Emery and Aston Villa confront their goalkeeping future, with James Trafford emerging as a serious contender to address what may soon become a pressing need.
