With the launch of Love Island All Stars series three, fans are eagerly returning to the South African villa to watch former Islanders reignite old flames and forge new connections. As the drama unfolds for a new batch of ITV legends, attention turns to the romantic fortunes of those who found love in the first two seasons. So, which couples managed to make their reality TV romances last in the real world?
Love Island All Stars Series One: Lasting Love Stories
The inaugural All Stars series in 2024 brought together 25 familiar faces from the show's history, creating a whirlwind of drama and romance. Among the iconic contestants were Hannah Elizabeth, Casey O'Gorman, Georgia Harrison, Anton Danyluk, Jess Gale, and Callum Jones. While many pairings were fleeting, two couples emerged with relationships built to last beyond the final.
The most successful pairing from that season is undoubtedly Molly Smith and Tom Clare. The glamorous couple, who won the series, captivated viewers with their undeniable chemistry. Their connection proved authentic, leading to a romantic engagement in September 2025 in Dubai, where Tom proposed with a stunning pear-cut diamond ring. Reports now suggest the northern pair are planning a wedding in South Africa, to honour the location where they first met and fell in love.
Another series one success story is Josh Ritchie and Sophie Piper. Josh committed to Rochelle Humes's sister during the show, and their relationship has grown steadily stronger since. The couple regularly share affectionate posts on social media, with Sophie confirming their continued romance just before Christmas. Josh frequently posts snaps from their luxury holidays, showcasing a partnership that has truly stood the test of time.
Love Island All Stars Series Two: A Single Success
The second season in 2025 saw the return of serial-dater Casey O'Gorman for his third villa stint. He coupled up with Gabby Allen, and the pair went on to win the series. However, their romance was short-lived, ending in a split announced in May 2025. Other couples from that season, including Curtis Pritchard and Ekin-Su Cülcüloğlu, Elma Pazar and Sammy Root, Ronnie Vint and Harriett Blackmore, and Olivia Hawkins and Marcel Somerville, also parted ways after filming wrapped.
Despite the high turnover, one couple from series two has defied the odds. Grace Jackson and Luca Bish are happily dating off-camera. Luca was instantly smitten with the model, and their relationship flourished once the show ended. The former fishmonger made it official during a lavish beach dinner in Dubai, asking Grace to be his girlfriend.
In a significant step, the couple moved in together in October 2025, with Luca joyfully announcing on social media that Grace had become a 'London girly'. They continue to share loved-up tributes and photos online, celebrating their first Christmas together and heading into 2026 as a solid unit.
The Verdict on All Stars Romance
The track record for lasting love from the Love Island All Stars spin-off shows it's a rare achievement. From the combined casts of series one and two, only three couples remain together as series three commences. The journey from the sun-soaked villa to everyday life proves challenging for most, with the intense environment not always translating to sustainable relationships. However, for winners Molly and Tom, and the steady pairs of Josh and Sophie and Grace and Luca, the All Stars experience provided the foundation for genuine, ongoing love stories. As a new group of Islanders enters the villa, they will no doubt be hoping to join this exclusive club of survivors.
