Birmingham City Council is actively investigating potential compromises after facing significant backlash for its divisive crackdown on busking in the city centre.
A Clash Over City Centre Sound
The local authority controversially introduced new rules this summer, implementing a Public Spaces Protection Order (PSPO) that bans musical instruments and amplification equipment on specific streets. The council justified the move, stating it had received a "significant and consistent number of complaints" from both residents and businesses concerning noise pollution.
However, the decision was met with fierce opposition from the city's musical community. Buskers and performers have argued that the stringent restrictions risk turning Birmingham into a "cultural wasteland." An online petition started by Black Country duo GANS, which has been signed by more than 1,500 people and shared by The Libertines' Pete Doherty, describes the PSPO as "draconian."
Seeking a Harmonious Solution
Amid the ongoing controversy, a recent council report has revealed that officials are now exploring the feasibility of a "consent/permitting scheme" for busking. This potential compromise has been previously suggested by performers, with some pointing to the successful Busk in London model as a possible template.
The report noted that a "constructive meeting" was held with the band GANS in October, where ideas for supporting music while protecting the locality were welcomed. The council is now awaiting a proposal from the band, who are working with a Night-Time Economy Ambassador on an "industry-led solution."
Despite these discussions, Sajeela Naseer, the council's Director of Regulation and Enforcement, acknowledged that a feasible scheme has not yet been identified. She emphasised that the door remains open to suggestions, stating, "If anyone wishes to approach us and make suggestions on how we can potentially bring music into the city centre in a positive way, we're always open to suggestions."
Balancing Noise and Vibrancy
Ms. Naseer also provided context for the council's tough stance, highlighting the extreme noise issues they had to address. She cited instances of individuals playing recorded music or "banging a saucepan for money for 12 hours a day," creating a statutory nuisance. She stressed the need to balance the rights of residents and businesses against those wishing to make music.
The PSPO has received strong support from many city centre businesses. One business reported that staff had suffered from migraines and anxiety due to the constant noise, while another said their shop door had to be kept closed, making the interior unbearably hot. Since the PSPO was introduced, feedback has been positive, with one business stating the "city centre now feels safer and more welcoming."
The council has confirmed that any future permitting scheme would need to be run independently of its enforcement activities to avoid a conflict of interest. Initial explorations found no interest from Central BID in administering such a scheme, as they did not want to undermine the PSPO's positive impact.
