The latest series of The Traitors on the BBC has viewers gripped not just by the game's inherent deceit, but by a sprawling conspiracy theory that suggests the entire cast is secretly connected. As the 2026 edition hosted by Claudia Winkleman delves deeper, online detectives are piecing together a potential family tree linking the 22 contestants.
The Roots of the Conspiracy
The theory gained traction partly due to a prominent portrait in the castle entrance, featuring all the contestants' faces on a family tree. An ominous message accompanies it: "Beware of the people who you trust like they are your own blood – the sharpest daggers are handed over at the table by trusted hands." This, combined with the already-revealed secret mother-daughter duo Judy and Roxy and the confirmed couple Ellie and Ross, has set the internet alight with speculation about further hidden links.
Contestants Under the Microscope
Fans are scrutinising every interaction for clues. Personal trainer Jack, 29, and hairstylist Jessie, 28, have raised eyebrows with their instant closeness. Their supportive exchanges, including Jack saying "love you" and "I couldn't be more proud of you," have led to theories they are siblings, a couple, or best friends who knew each other before the show.
Meanwhile, connections based on geography are also in play. Some believe traitor Rachel and faithful Matthew know each other because they are both from Northern Ireland, though Matthew is gay, ruling out a romantic link. Another pair drawing suspicion are Stephen and Matthew, after Matthew mentioned wanting a house in the Highlands, where Stephen is from.
More Potential Family Ties
The speculation doesn't end there. Viewers are also convinced Stephen and Jack have a prior connection, pointing to an instinctive, familiar touch during a challenge. Perhaps the most visually compelling theory is that secret traitor Fiona and faithful Reece are mother and son, with many commenting on their striking resemblance on social media.
With the family tree portrait looming over the castle and Claudia Winkleman at the helm, the question of whether this is an elaborate production ruse or mere coincidence continues to fuel fan debates. As the game progresses, only time will tell if these theories of secret connections in The Traitors 2026 hold any truth.
