Political Clash Over Solihull's Historic Barston Bridge Consultation
A significant dispute has emerged between Meriden and Solihull East MP Saqib Bhatti and Solihull Council regarding the public consultation on the future of Barston Bridge. The MP has expressed deep concern that the process appears biased, with closure being presented as an acceptable outcome without adequate consideration of its practical impacts on the local community.
Safety Concerns and Financial Constraints Threaten Bridge
Barston Bridge, a historic structure dating back to 1859 that carries Barston Lane over the River Blythe to the east of Barston village, faces an uncertain future due to pressing safety issues. The council, grappling with financial limitations, estimates a £2 million bill for a full repair to replace the bridge with a structure capable of handling 40-tonne highway loading.
The alternative, and highly contentious, option under consultation is to close the bridge to all motorised traffic, permitting access only for pedestrians and cyclists. This vital route is used by farmers, commuters, and residents, with over 1,000 vehicles crossing it daily, making its potential closure a major local issue.
MP and Local Councillors Voice Strong Opposition
In a strongly worded statement, MP Saqib Bhatti criticised the council's approach, stating: "I am deeply concerned this consultation does not appear to be a genuinely open or neutral exercise. Closure is being treated as an acceptable outcome without proper consideration of real-world impacts." He emphasised that residents deserve a balanced, evidence-led process that genuinely reflects community preference.
His concerns have been echoed by local Knowle councillors Edward Fitter and Dave Pinwell. Councillor Pinwell argued that limiting the consultation to two extreme options is unhelpful, particularly as closure would leave the village with only a single exit route. He suggested the consultation should have initially focused on establishing what villagers and bridge users actually require for the future.
Council Defends Consultation Process Amidst Criticism
In response, a Solihull Council spokesperson defended the ongoing public consultation, which remains open until February. The spokesperson clarified that no final decision has been made regarding the bridge's fate. The council asserts it is consulting on the two long-term options to comprehensively understand local views and the associated impacts.
The authority has provided detailed background information on the bridge and both potential options—including their benefits, impacts, and funding implications—on a dedicated consultation webpage. Furthermore, the council has engaged directly with local residents, farmers, and business owners, recently holding a drop-in session in Barston to address questions and gather feedback.
A full report detailing the consultation results will be presented at a future environment and infrastructure decision session, where the relevant cabinet member will determine which option to proceed with. Councillor Ken Hawkins, the council's portfolio holder for infrastructure, has previously acknowledged the financial challenges, stating last year that funds are not available for a full repair and expressing sympathy for residents if the closure route is pursued.
