A Sutton Coldfield businessman has been ordered to demolish a large extension on his family home, which neighbours likened to a "football director's box". Mani Singh constructed the 3-metre (9-foot) high grey dormer on the rear of his £415,000 property without obtaining planning permission, sparking complaints from residents in Lowlands Avenue, Streetly.
Neighbours Label Extension an 'Ugly Eyesore'
Local residents described the structure as an "ugly eyesore" that blocks light and disrupts the character of the quiet suburban area. The dormer, which includes a loft conversion and skylights, was built after Mr Singh moved into the three-bedroom house in 2024. Following complaints, he applied for retrospective planning permission, but the application was ultimately rejected by Walsall Council.
Residents Speak Out
Liz Deakin, 63, who has lived on the street for 35 years, said: "The building is very large and affects people nearby. It blocks light and looks directly into gardens and properties, making it very intrusive. It reminds me of a director's box at big football stadiums, not appropriate for a quiet suburban area." She noted that Mr Singh initially applied for a smaller structure, which was approved, but then built the larger version instead.
Neighbour Cath Tandy, 75, who moved into her home in 1985, added: "Before, you could see the pitched garage roof at the back of the garden. Now all you can see is a huge wall. It's like being in a prison exercise yard. I used to have lots of sunlight in the evenings, but now it's dark most of the time."
Council Decision and Enforcement
Determined to voice their concerns, residents hired a minibus to attend the council meeting where the decision was made. The council ruled that the dormer was "incongruous" with the area and breached planning laws. Mr Singh now has six months to demolish the extension or appeal the decision. He has been approached for comment but has not yet responded.
